My car insurance jumped. Who’s affordable and actually good?

My car insurance bill just jumped up by over $40 a month because I’m now driving to the office after working from home for years. I live in Miami, Florida, and I’m a 65-year-old looking for full coverage that won’t break the bank. I’ve gotten quotes from some of the big names, but the prices are all over the place. Who do you guys actually use and find affordable while still having decent coverage when things go wrong? Any real-life experiences and numbers would be a huge help!